The Clarity Column
Advice Isn’t Enough

The shidduch ended. Again. This had been happening to Zeldy for years.
She met genuinely wonderful, interesting men who, both on paper and in real life, were pretty much what she was looking for. And still, something in her didn’t settle, so she ended it. Every time. And now, it had just happened again.
This time, it was Nachum. They had gone out ten times, and Zeldy couldn’t point to anything significant that was wrong. Nachum had been ready to move forward for a while already, but he was patient, giving her the space and time she said she needed. Still, Zeldy felt the dating was stagnant, and it had reached the point where a decision needed to be made: either move forward or step away.
She couldn’t decide. On one hand, there was no clear reason to end it—he really was what she had said she was looking for. And yet, she couldn’t give the green light, because she didn’t feel at peace with it.
In her confusion and distress, Zeldy found herself speaking to almost anyone who would listen. If advice was what she wanted, advice was what she got. Plenty of it. All well-meaning, yet not truly helpful. The message was always the same: it sounded like an amazing shidduch, and she should go ahead. As for her discomfort? That would fade after marriage. How did they know? To them, it was obvious.
Her rebbetzin offered a different kind of guidance: take a two-week break, and then see how she felt. Zeldy decided to follow that direction.
Those two weeks were not easy. And at the end of them, she was no closer to a decision. She still wasn’t ready to say yes, so it became a no. Not because of anything specific, but because she had come to recognize that more time or more dating wasn’t going to change anything.
She accepted the suggestion of a two-week break because it offered some immediate relief from the pressure. It felt like solid, thoughtful advice from a wise woman, the kind of guidance she knew others had followed, and for the moment, the decision was off her shoulders.
But the relief didn’t last. As the two-week mark approached, the pressure only intensified until it was unbearable.
In the end, instead of resolving the question, she found herself needing to escape the pressure itself. She ended her agony the only way she could—by ending the shidduch.
The Power of the Right Question
The real reason all the advice failed is that it was advice. What Zeldy needed wasn’t more input. She needed insight.
The most helpful thing she could have been given—and the one thing she didn’t get—was a single, pointed question: Why is this happening? Is there some underlying struggle she experiences during dating that’s driving this pattern?
She didn’t need to be told what to do; she needed help understanding what was really going on.
Before her next shidduch, Zeldy reached out for advice again. This time, the coach approached things differently—not by telling her what to do, but by helping her uncover what was really happening inside her.
Slowly, a clearer picture emerged of how dating felt for her. A part of her felt like a little child, utterly unprepared for marriage. That childlike part panicked at the thought of marriage, and understandably so.
Whereas before she had only received reassurance, now she had self-understanding. With that clarity, and the right guidance, she regained a sense of control and could see a way forward—one that took into account the complexity and nuance of her personality and life experiences.
Shidduch Crisis
Zeldy’s story, sadly, is not unique. Tens of thousands of our wonderful young men and women are finding dating difficult. They spend years in shidduchim, navigating the dating scene, only to experience repeated frustration, hurt, and disappointment. What was once a relatively rare challenge has now become common. Numerous shidduch initiatives have been launched, yet the problem continues to grow. Clearly, what has been done so far isn’t enough. We need to be smarter about this, and we need to be honest and open about it.
Having researched, written, taught, and coached in the dating sphere for many years, we are convinced that many singles are being held back by internal barriers and inner struggles. For some, it’s a persistent pattern of choosing incompatible partners. For others, it’s difficulty forming an emotional connection. Some have complex personalities that leave them conflicted about what they truly want. Others are unaware of how fear or anxiety controls them, making dating unnerving.
Rarely are those affected aware of these underlying issues, and even more rarely do they understand why they feel stuck. Almost never do they know what would be an effective way to navigate these inner struggles. Instead, they are likely to assume they simply haven’t met the right person yet—and so they continue through years of unproductive, often painful dating.
Knowledge is Power
It doesn’t have to be this way. Once they figure out what’s really holding them back, it’s usually possible to work with it or around it. Most of the time, the issue is minor, and just being aware of it is already a huge step forward. With the right insights and tools, someone struggling with these inner challenges can greatly increase their chances of success.
We also need to remember something important: not everyone experiences dating the same way. For most, shidduchim feel fairly straightforward. But for a substantial minority, it’s harder; there’s a lot of internal pushback. And when that happens, it’s easy to assume the problem lies in the person they’re dating.
The truth is, most of the time, that’s not what’s going on. The difficulty isn’t the person. It’s their dating process itself. That’s why, even after many dating opportunities, things still haven’t worked out. Switching the person they date doesn’t usually fix it, because the real obstacle isn’t the partner; it’s something inside them that hasn’t been addressed yet.
When a shidduch isn’t coming together, ask yourself: “Why is this happening?” Take a moment to look back at past experiences and notice any patterns, even loose ones. Ask: “Is there something I need to notice about myself?” What feels like repeated frustration or random difficulty may not just be about the other person or the situation. It can reveal habits, tendencies, or reactions that keep resurfacing. Simply noticing these patterns is the first step toward understanding yourself more deeply and approaching your dating journey with greater clarity.
For those who want guidance on how to do this, we’ve gathered game-changing insights and reflections at datewell.org. These aren’t “rules” or quick fixes; they’re tools to help you think more clearly about your dating journey.
So-Me: What Is Your Dating Style?
To help those who struggle with dating and aren’t sure why, DateWell created “That’s So Me!”—a lighthearted, engaging way to uncover what’s really happening beneath the surface of your shidduch journey. It features twenty characters, each representing a different personality and approach to dating.
The goal isn’t to give answers or tell you what to do. Instead, it’s to help you better understand yourself and your dating style, while offering insights and tools to navigate your shidduch journey more thoughtfully and successfully.
Chaim has been dating for a couple of years and has had a number of shidduchim. Quite a few went on for a while, and looked for a time to have real potential. In the end, though, Chaim felt unable to continue. Most of the shidduchim ended because Chaim felt stressed, uneasy, and very stuck. But why, after so many promising starts, did things fall down?
Chaim went onto DateWell’s “That’s so me!” hoping to get some insight. At first, he came across Anxious Abigail and found parts of her story familiar—the stress, the emotional drain, the sense of overwhelm. “Maybe that’s me,” he thought. “I do get really anxious when I date.” But something didn’t sit right. “I’m not usually an anxious person,” he realized. While some of it resonated, it didn’t quite capture the full picture—so he kept looking.
Chaim was drawn to Commitment-Phobic Connie. “That sounds a lot like me,” he thought. “Dating feels easier at the beginning, but I tend to pull away after a few dates. Maybe this is me?” he wondered. But again, he wasn’t sure, as he didn’t experience the kind of panic that often comes with this type, nor the typical strong sense that something was wrong.
When Chaim met Indecisive Izzy, the penny dropped. “That’s so spot on. It describes me to a tee,” he said. “I get stuck for no clear reason. I make endless pros and cons lists, talk everything through with people… and still don’t move forward.” What really hit home was the part about how the indecisive type sometimes sabotages the relationship just to avoid making a decision, and then feels relief when it ends. “That’s exactly what’s happened to me so many times,” Chaim realized.
That realization brought a wave of relief. “Clearly, I’m not the only one experiencing this,” Chaim said. He felt seen and understood. “It seems what I’ve been going through is a real thing.”
Encouraged by the clarity, Chaim clicked through to explore more. He found helpful content that explained how indecision can show up in dating, along with some initial tools for moving past the constant paralysis. Inspired by this new insight, he sought advice from a coach about how to avoid his indecision from calling the shots.
There are currently 20 “so-me” characters, covering the vast majority of people who are prone to getting stuck in shidduchim. Check out Ambivalent Avram, Complex Kayla, Guarded Gavi, and the other types, and see if you find yourself exclaiming: “That’s so me!”
Visit DateWell’s “That’s So Me!” to see for yourself.
You can reach the authors at yossi@datewell.org and devora@datewell.org.
About the contributors
Devora Krasnianski
Devora Krasnianski founded Adai Ad. A dating mentor, author, and speaker, she helps people navigate dating and marriage.
More by and about Devora Krasnianski →Rabbi Dr. Yossi Ives
Rabbi Dr. Yossi Ives is a dating coach, author of Shidduch Success, and community rav in Pomona, New York.
More by and about Rabbi Dr. Yossi Ives →















































































