Worth passing along

MENTAL HEALTH · PESACH

When Pesach Prep Goes Too Far

Understanding OCD and the quest for certainty

Matzah, parsley and a glass of wine in warm natural light
Editorial illustration · Finding a calmer path to Pesach.

“Chag kasher v’sameach!” we happily wish to each other as Pesach is approaching. But not everyone experiences the holiday preparation or the holiday itself with much happiness and they may be very worried about whether they have performed the rites in a properly kosher manner.

Along with the holiday preparations, some people also take on extra pressures that have little to do with the actual laws of Pesach. Social messages often frame the season as a time for “spring cleaning” and de-cluttering, which are tasks unrelated to the requirement to remove chametz. These added expectations and demands can increase stress during an already busy time. It can be helpful to pause and ask: Is now really a helpful time to reorganize the closets and clean the bedroom baseboards? Setting priorities that work for you and your family can make the lead-up to the holiday far more manageable.

A related issue that can surface around Pesach is Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD). For some people, the many details of holiday preparation can become a target for obsessive thoughts and compulsive behaviors or mental acts that go well beyond the intent of Jewish law.

This article explores how OCD can “hijack” Pesach preparation and observance. OCD fosters a binary way of thinking such that individuals have an overwhelming need for absolute certainty that every law and practice has been carried out perfectly. This preoccupation shifts their focus from the religious rituals to anxiety-fueled rituals that can take over. This article examines the relationship between Pesach and OCD and considers how to find a healthier middle path—the Shvil HaZahav, the “golden road”—so that Pesach can be observed in a way that is both kosher and b’simcha, with joy.

What Is OCD?

OCD is a common mental health condition with a lifetime prevalence rate of approximately 3% of the population, meaning that roughly 10 million people in the U.S. alone may suffer from OCD. It usually begins in childhood or adolescence, though adult onset is also possible.

The disorder involves obsessions, compulsions, or usually, both. Obsessions are intrusive, unwanted thoughts, urges, or images that cause significant distress. The distress is often experienced as anxiety, but sometimes as intense feelings of disgust or shame. Compulsions are repetitive actions or mental rituals performed to reduce that distress or prevent a feared outcome.

While compulsions may provide short-term relief, they reinforce and maintain the cycle of OCD in the long-term. Someone might recognize that their compulsion is illogical, such as repeatedly checking a locked door or avoiding driving past a hospital out of fear of contamination, but nonetheless feel unable to stop.

OCD exists on a continuum, but it becomes a clinical disorder when the obsessions and compulsions consume significant time, interfere with responsibilities and relationships, or restrict daily life. People may spend hours washing, checking, or reviewing actions in their minds, or avoid situations entirely to prevent triggering unwanted intrusive thoughts. Over time, the strain can affect work, school, relationships, and overall well-being.

A Disease of Doubt

OCD is often misunderstood as simply being very neat or organized or clean. In reality, it’s better described as a disease of doubt. People with OCD feel an intense need to be completely certain that a feared outcome won’t occur. But absolute certainty doesn’t exist in everyday life and there are no 100% risk-free options, which OCD struggles to accept.

OCD tends to focus on themes that are important to the individual and it is a “shape-shifter”, meaning that the content of the OCD can change over time, depending on what matters to someone at that time. For example, a student might obsess over perfect notes and compulsively re-write them, but in later years worry about whether they’re in the “right” relationship and try to test that by taking relationship quizzes to know for sure or compare their relationship to their friends’ relationships, and subsequently may shift to consuming fears of harming a loved one prompting them to avoid being alone with their baby. OCD adapts to whatever content feels very important. It also tends to flare during “pinch points”, which are periods of stress or major life transitions.

OCD and Pesach

Religious observance does not cause OCD. However, when faith is central to a person’s life, it can become a focus for the disorder. OCD attacks where it can make the most mischief. Like any good bully, OCD goes after the things that will get your attention and matter to you; otherwise, you would just shrug off the insults of the bully or the needling doubts of OCD. When OCD attaches itself to religious practice, it is called Scrupulosity OCD. Scrupulosity OCD is not about being more halachic or machmir (stringent). If you have a halacha question, please consult your local Rabbi. Scrupulosity OCD is not limited to any specific religion. My clinical psychology practice has worked with religious people of diverse faiths who have struggled with the condition.

Pesach, with its detailed preparations and religious rituals, can present many opportunities for doubt. Checking food labels, searching for chametz, and ensuring everything is done properly are all part of the holiday. For someone with OCD, however, these tasks can spiral into endless checking, washing, researching, or seeking reassurance (e.g., repeated calls to the Rabbi for reassurance or mentally reviewing things in your mind) in an effort to feel absolutely certain that nothing was missed or done incorrectly.

The problem is that perfect certainty is impossible. Instead of strengthening religious practice, OCD can pull people away from their actual values by turning meaningful observance into a stressful quest for impossible guarantees.

It can be helpful to ask yourself: Does my Rabbi or Rebbetzin prepare for Pesach this way? If your behavior goes far beyond typical community practice, OCD may be driving the process.

Effective OCD Treatment: Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP)

Unfortunately, OCD is often unrecognized and misdiagnosed, even among mental health professionals. Studies have shown that it can take many years from the onset of OCD symptoms until a person receives an accurate diagnosis of OCD and begins effective, evidence-based treatment. If OCD is affecting your daily life, effective help is available. The most effective treatment for OCD is Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP), a specialized form of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT).

Mental health professionals with specialized training and experience in ERP help people gradually face situations that trigger obsessive fears (Exposure) while resisting the urge to perform compulsions (Response Prevention), with Rabbinic consultation as needed. With repeated practice, individuals learn they can tolerate uncertainty and distress without resorting to compulsions or avoidance for relief, thereby building resiliency and eliminating compulsions.

OCD likes binary black and white thinking where there is no ambiguity and zero doubt. The goal of ERP is to move towards living in a middle, gray zone without perfect certainty. Treatment helps people create a mindset shift from chasing elusive guarantees to instead, living meaningfully despite uncertainty. Emphasis is upon accepting that we can never be fully sure that we have done things perfectly. Feared outcomes could still happen. And we can’t answer unanswerable questions.

After successfully completing ERP treatment, people report that they no longer spend hours engaging in obsessions and compulsions and are able to focus on what truly matters to them. For some, that means enjoying Pesach for the first time while fulfilling religious obligations in positive ways, cooking with their children, sharing meals with family, and engaging with the holiday’s meaning rather than its fears.

Wishing everyone a chag kasher v’sameach, with a reasonable focus on both the kasher, and also the sameach.

This article is provided as psychoeducational information for the community and is not intended as psychological treatment and does not constitute creation of a doctor-patient relationship. If you are experiencing a mental health emergency, call 9-8-8, the national behavioral health emergency number, or go to your nearest emergency room.

Dr. Selena Snow

Dr. Selena Snow

Dr. Selena Snow is a licensed psychologist and the founder and director of The Snow Psychology Group in Rockville, Maryland. Her practice specializes in CBT and other evidence-based treatment for depression, anxiety, OCD and trauma, with in-person care and telehealth services. She earned her PhD in clinical psychology from the University of Maryland in 1999 and completed her internship at Yale University School of Medicine. A Fellow of the Maryland Psychological Association, she writes about practical tools for emotional well-being.

More from Dr. Snow →

Continue reading

About the contributors

Licensed psychologist · Founder, The Snow Psychology Group

Dr. Selena Snow

Dr. Selena Snow is a licensed psychologist and the founder and director of The Snow Psychology Group in Rockville, Maryland. Her practice specializes in CBT and other evidence-based treatment for depression, anxiety, OCD and trauma, with in-person care and telehealth services. She earned her PhD in clinical psychology from the University of Maryland in 1999 and completed her internship at Yale University School of Medicine. A Fellow of the Maryland Psychological Association, she writes about practical tools for emotional well-being.

More by and about Dr. Selena Snow

See Also

IN THE PAGES OF THE JOURNAL

Names you can trust.

A few of the businesses and organizations that have shared their message in Washington Jewish Journal.

Make your next impression

The Washington Collection · Five featured pieces

A little Washington. A lot of character.

Shop the collection →
THE JOURNAL, AT YOUR DOOR

A full year of WJJ for $99.

The people, ideas and conversations shaping Jewish American life—delivered home.

Subscribe for $99
FROM THE WJJ ARCHIVE

More issues you may enjoy

A few more editions worth keeping.

WhatsApp
Get Washington Jewish Journal ↗

Let’s talk.

Send us a message. Our team will reply to your email.